When a cruise line launches a brand new ship, there’s often a complete frenzy around it - everybody wants to get a cruise booked as soon as possible to test it out for themselves. I’m not one of those people - in fact, I very rarely will cruise on a brand new cruise ship during its first season of operating.
In this article, I’m going to tell you why. I’m going to tell you exactly why I avoid cruising on brand new cruise ships, despite this position being quite controversial to so many people out there.
Across my channels (and on this website!), I’ve shown you in the past what it’s like to cruise on brand new ships, but I personally don’t enjoy the brand-new ships as much as I tend to enjoy the slightly older ones. I’m not talking about ships that are 10+ years old - I’m referring to ships that have completed at least their first season - in other words, they’re not ‘new’ anymore.
If you’re one of those cruisers who absolutely adores the brand new ships and wouldn’t think about cruising on any others, this post is for you - read on, and let me open your eyes to a whole new world of ships that are waiting for you! If you enjoy the older ships like me, then hopefully you’ll agree with my viewpoint throughout this post!
If you enjoy this content, then please support me by simply sharing my website with anyone else that you think might enjoy it - this is the quickest and easiest way to support an independent creator like me! In addition, come over and subscribe to my YouTube channel - this is completely free of charge for you to do, and it massively helps me to reach more people. To find me on YouTube, just search ‘Fraser at Sea’, or click here to go to my channel homepage now.
If you would rather watch a YouTube video on this topic rather than read this page, you’re in luck. You’ll find a link to a YouTube video that I put together to cover these points - just click the video below to watch it now!
Okay, let’s get started with the seven reasons why I usually refuse to cruise on brand new cruise ships - some of these might just surprise you…
1. The Costs
The first reason that I often don’t cruise on brand new ships is that they are usually so much more expensive than the slightly older ships. Did you know that you can sometimes pay double the average cruise fare to get onboard one of a cruise line’s newer ships versus one that launched just a year or two prior?
At the point of writing this post, the newest class of cruise ship from Royal Caribbean is Icon Class, which consists of ships including Icon of the Seas, Star of the Seas and Legend of the Seas. I haven’t cruised on any of these ships yet, because the rest of the Royal Caribbean fleet is so much more appealing to me from a price point perspective.
If I look at Royal Caribbean’s ‘Oasis Class’ (so ships like Symphony of the Seas, Oasis of the Seas, Harmony of the Seas, Wonder of the Seas etc), it doesn’t make financial sense for me to pay so much more to get onto an Icon Class ship when these ships are so impressive in their own right. They might be a couple of years older, but they’re still absolutely incredible ships!
Royal Caribbean’s ‘Icon Class’ of ships are incredibly impressive ships, but the price point to get onboard is so much higher than the rest of the fleet! © Fraser at Sea.
2. The Solo Supplement!
If you’ve followed me for a while, you’ll already know that the topic of solo supplements is one of my biggest frustrations about the cruise industry in general. If you’re unfamiliar, a solo supplement is an additional fee charged to a solo passenger to allow them to enjoy the luxury of their own cabin.
I’ll give you an example to bring this to life. You might see a cruise line advertising cruises at $599pp, which would seem like a great price initially. When you then proceed to book as a couple sharing the cabin, you are indeed able to book for $599pp - great news! If you do the same as a solo passenger, the price might jump to something like $999 for you, or maybe even the full price that a pair sharing a cabin would have to pay.
Frustrating, right?!
On brand new ships, I tend to find that the solo supplement rates are incredibly high. This is probably due to the fact that overall demand to get onto the ship is very high, and therefore the cruise line can charge the full double-fare, as the cabin could otherwise be occupied by two passengers.
Personally, I won’t pay the full double-fare as a solo supplement, as I fundamentally disagree with the industry charging it in the first place. If the solo supplement rate is really high, I’m far more likely to take my money elsewhere and spend it with a cruise line that’s a little more welcoming to solo passengers!
Here’s an example of what can happen to the prices when you switch from cruising as a pair to cruising solo - the prices at the bottom are the solo prices, and the percentages are the solo supplements! © Fraser at Sea.
3. Teething Problems…
You’ve booked your cruise, you’ve looked forward to it for months, and now you’re onboard. At this point, the last thing you want is teething problems associated with a brand new ship resulting in you not enjoying the experience as much as you had hoped.
In the past, there have been examples of ships launching with some facilities not operating as planned. For example, the top decks haven’t been fully finished and therefore the swimming pools aren’t open, or the main restaurant or dining room isn’t fully operational yet. I’ve even heard of examples in the past where the production team are onboard and ready to perform, but the technical aspect of the theatre experiences issues, and therefore the onboard shows have had to be cancelled - not ideal when you pay all of that money to be on a maiden cruise, right?!
Personally, if I’m paying more than I usually would to cruise on a ship during the maiden voyage, I want a flawless experience. Realistically, I can’t guarantee that I’m going to get that, and for that reason I tend to steer clear.
Want to experience a fully operational cruise ship? You might want to dodge the maiden voyage… © Fraser at Sea.
4. Cruise Changes and Cancellations.
One of the aspects of maiden cruises that I can’t get onboard with is the fact that they’re almost entirely ‘subject to change’ in some cases.
Over the last few years, there have been examples where ships take a little longer to complete than expected, which then results in the first cruise with paying passengers being cancelled. This isn’t too major a problem if you’re able to drive to the port, and therefore don’t have many other travel arrangements booked, but it’s a real headache if you then need to cancel hotels, flights, transfers and more.
My local homeport is Southampton in England, and we don’t get many maiden voyages, so I’d usually need to plan carefully in order to get to a foreign port. Due to the uncertainty with delays, I’m not fully sold on booking one.
The other end of the scale here is when a ship is ready early. Passengers pay a significant premium to be able to say that they’re among the first passengers to ever cruise on a specific ship, but sometimes the cruise line is able to sign the ship off early. Rather than keep it empty, they take the opportunity to offer additional ‘shakedown cruises’, or cruises for travel agents and media guests, therefore meaning that the maiden cruise that you’d booked on to is no more…
Celebrity Beyond, taken as she departed on a media sailing from Southampton ahead of her official Maiden Voyage. © Fraser at Sea.
5. Uncertainty Onboard.
Personally, I like to have a plan. I have plans for my personal life, for my work life, and just about everything else in between. When I cruise, I like to have a plan for what I want to do and see onboard, and roughly when. When you board a brand new cruise ship, it can be difficult to do this, as there is limited information online to support your planning.
Okay, this isn’t a major problem if the cruise line has previously launched ships within the same class, but when this is the first of this type of cruise ship to ever launch, I begin to stress a little (which will sound ridiculous to many, I know…). I’m not able to go to YouTube to help me plan my trip - I’m left trying to figure it all out from a PDF of a deck plan - argh!
So, why am I like this? Well, in the past I did board a cruise ship following very little planning. I took a 7-night cruise onboard Symphony of the Seas, one of Royal Caribbean’s Oasis Class ships. Before the cruise, I naively thought that I wouldn’t need to do much research, because I’d been on ships of a similar size before and therefore it couldn’t be too different from them. I was completely wrong.
After about an hour of being onboard, I was completely overwhelmed by the ship - I had no idea where anything was, couldn’t find my cabin, and didn’t even know which direction the front of the ship was - it was a situation that I vowed to never repeat for my own sake!
I cruised onboard Symphony of the Seas, and was almost immediately completely overwhelmed by the ship. Now, I do my research before I step onboard any ship! © Fraser at Sea.
6. Maiden Cruises are usually BUSY!
Maiden cruises are usually fully sold out, and so there are LOTS of passengers onboard as a result. Not only that, but these cruises are usually incredibly popular with people who want to see and experience as much of the ship as quickly as possible. This could be due to the fact that they’re brand new cruisers, loyal passengers of that cruise line who are excited to see something new, or maybe they’re fellow content creators who are keen to showcase as much of the ship as possible to their audiences.
When I find myself in an environment like this, I really struggle to sit down and relax, because I always feel as though I’m missing out on something. I can only imagine how I’d feel on a maiden cruise where it’s all so new - I don’t think I’d want to sleep for the first few nights of the cruise…!
If you are considering booking onto a maiden cruise, please be sure to diarise some time to take care of YOU - don’t run around the ship crazy the entire time - remember to take some ‘time out’ to breathe and relax!
Maiden voyages are usually sold out - that’s a lot of passengers trying to see the ship as quickly as possible! © Fraser at Sea.
7. The Crew are still Learning…
Before I expand on this one, let me be clear - this isn’t a criticism of the crew whatsoever. On a brand new cruise ship, the crew are also working hard to settle in from both a work and a personal point of view. They’ve arrived in this completely new environment, and are likely adjusting to processes they’re unfamiliar with, and potentially also reporting to managers that they haven’t before - there’s a lot for them to get to grips with over the first few cruises!
While this is completely normal human behaviour, I don’t want to pay a premium for an experience that people are still mastering. I’m repeatedly amazed by crew members across the cruise industry, both by their work ethic but also by how easy they make the whole thing look. That’s part of the ‘magic of cruising’ to me, and I wouldn’t want to pay the premiums associated with a brand new cruise ship to dampen that.
This can be particularly evident in the situation where the cruise line launches brand new venues on a new ship that aren’t seen elsewhere in the fleet. In this scenario, even the veteran crew members who have completed lots of contracts aren’t able to support those who are learning, as it’s new for everyone!
If a venue is brand new and never seen before elsewhere on the fleet, the crew will naturally take time to familiarise themselves with it, and the processes that come with it. © Fraser at Sea.
That’s just some of the reasons why I don’t (at the point of writing this article) take maiden cruises - there’s too much at stake from my point of view.
If you’ve enjoyed this post, then please support me by sharing it with anyone else that you think might enjoy it. Please also come across and subscribe to my YouTube channel - this is completely free for you to do, and it massively helps me to reach more people with my content!
Why not now head to another of my posts, which you can find via the menu at the top of your screen, or there are some highlighted posts below. You’ll also find a link below to a YouTube video that I filmed while cruising onboard Norwegian Luna a few weeks after her launch to the public.
Happy cruising!